In the play , the chorus repeatedly gives us moral lessons , often condemning pride , are we to take the proclamations of the chorus as the absolute truth , or is the chorus just as fallible As other characters ? Is pride really the catalyst for all the catastrophes of the play ? ( Oedipus Rex)

One of the really old ones, I actually put some effort into this one.

 

 

oedipusrex_2100x1400_03

 

 

The  Chorus does indeed give the audience many moral lessons according to that time and society .Acting as fourth wall of dialogue and even a dramatic enhancement to the already emotional and moral questioning play .Arguably pride is a major  factor which propels the action sequence and complexity of the play , but there are also key aspects that may control the events like fate or the will of the gods .It is among all of these reasons that audiences struggle with the sight of the fall of Oedipus from glorious king to a homeless, friendless and blind nomad  .

To understand fully the depth of the role and opinion of the chorus , concerning morality . Along with   the influence of the sin – pride on the characters and plot.  We will first go through a small introduction of   “Chorus” in the setting of a Greek play – later analyzing the objectionable actions or statements of characters like Oedipus and Jocasta.

As is the case with many other Greek plays , the chorus in Oedipus Rex is the voice of the society and traditions of ancient Greece . Their odes are filled with religious knowledge and submission towards the gods and the kings . They also provide a deeper , more philosophical journey into the themes of the play . In many plays the chorus had a role of action , or an ability to influence the action of the plot – but that is not in the case of Oedipus .  Here they dryly preach morals and pass judgments while invoking the help and curse of the gods . A curse initially on the one who brought forth the plague but by the end they to lose the moralistic , unforgiving tone , adopting sympathy and lost love for the damned king .

Of course the chorus has other roles to play . Sophocles himself , raised the importance of the chorus and even added more actors – they magnify the significance of the tragic nature of his play and give little relief from the already apparent doom .

Daniels and Scully the authors of “what is really  going on in Sophocles Theban plays “ wrote that .

 

“No feature of Greek tragedy is more intractable than the chorus “

 

(What is really  going on in Sophocles Theban plays)

 

The two basic moral lessons that the chorus does insist on giving the audience ,directly through speech, are obedience to the gods and loyalty towards their ruler . Both are the rules of the society , but this behavior is in contrast with the attitude of the nobility . They are humble and lack both the responsibility and hubris of the rulers to look towards to cure the disease that harms the land .

In the first ode they make a long prayer to the gods asking for a remedy and laying themselves at complete mercy . Acknowledging the full power or authority of oracles , which Oedipus and Jocasta do not . This may be deliberate to teach the masses a lesson about not angering the gods . To follow their commands , because the nobility cannot escape their wrath no matter how much they try .

Strangely at the beginning of the play while at the alter , they look towards Oedipus as a god himself . As he is the only one that can safe them – all responsibly is on his shoulders and like a good king he treats them like his children – with a sense of pride and defiance towards the gods .

 

“Come then my children : Leave the alter steps “

_ Oedpius Rex

 

It is after this order by Oedipus that the chorus enters with their  song and praise the powers of the gods . They call out their names , doing so giving a break for the action of the play and reminding the audience of authority .

 

“Let me pray to Athene , the immortal daughter of Zeus . And to Artemis her sister ..And to Apollo , bowman at the far butts of heaven “

_ – Oedipus rex , Parodus .

 

This does indeed show the religious ,pious side of the chorus of the play but one must remember . The gods do not make an appearance in the play , the closet to them are the oracles and the priests who do little to stop disaster . Oedipus In all glory and heavy headedness still makes more efforts of changing his troubled destiny then other characters. The plague came far long after the sin was committed, he was able to be default save the riddle and bring peace to land . It is a quality among leaders to be unapologetic of the decisions they make and  try by all means to reach the goal . The chorus and other characters barely try to alter what can be altered .Oedipus points out this flaw , even if he is blind to his own . The flaw,  that they could properly manage their own affairs. Waiting  till the brink of destruction to clear matters.

 

It is then in the second ode of the play , that the chorus again adopts a highly moralistic vocabulary , quite literally . They name social and personal sins , ironically the ones Oedipus possesses .

 

“The tyrant is a child of pride

Who drinks from his great sickening cup

Recklessness and vanity “

  • Oedipus Rex

 

Kings and princes have throughout history have been known more for their luxury and vanity than piety. The protagonist of the play is no exception, but can he really be blamed? When he calls for the blind prophet and insults him, in turn disrespecting the gods   the prophet returns the curse. This may also show his show of haughtiness. The prophet does not remain calm , just like Oedipus he becomes angry and agitated and relies on curses .  One common explanation of why Oedipus might have killed Lias in the forest is his royal upbringing. A prince would not be held highly accountable for the death of common people . The Thebans place him on a pedestal and treat him like a god – so obliviously he is going to think of himself as important and untouchable. It is evident in the way he talks about himself

 

“But I am a child of luck I cannot be dishonored”

  • Oedipus Rex

 

To conclude this part of the question , yes , the chorus provides moral lessons but they are not free of weakness or wrong doing . The chorus undergoes a change in character along side Oedipus , by the end of the play their last song becomes pessimistic and is unable to think of fate as justice . They remain loyal to Oedipus , the most royal one .

 

Now , towards the discussion of Pride as a catalyst for all the catastrophes in the play. For this may have to go the background of the play, to when the oracle first warned Jocasta and Lias about the terrible destiny of the child . It is not known if consulting oracles is a sin or not since it was common at the time . It is however as act of pride to defy an oracle , and this is done multiple throughout Oedipus Rex . The fact that mortals thinks that they can change or control the fate which the gods decide , is and act of blasphemy . It is pride and sin when Lias and Jocasta send the child to be killed in the plains , an act common of the Spartans . A Greek nation that let fate decide which children were to live and which were to die . It Is fear and pride that makes Oedipus run away from his new home after he learn of his destiny . He acts as god when he decides to run away , even if his intentions were innocent .

This is also his tragic flaw , the quality which makes him a hero in the eyes of the audience . He tries with all his might to prevent a curse but is unable to. His heart and efforts were in the right place . It could have been fear and not pride which motivated all the events prior to the scenes in the play .

The next display of his flaw is when he murders his real father on the road . This may have been due a sudden burst of anger or princely disposition but even at that time Oedipus was right . Lias had pushed his luck and perhaps something snapped inside of Oedipus . The very hand of fate perhaps took hold of him . Either way he let his ego get the better of his actions and judgment.

Oedipus has another flaw – a lack of insight. It was by strange chance that he solved the riddle of the sphinx and became king . Even the blind prophet tells him that his own eyes betray him , that is unable to see his true self . Jocasta insists that tempers like his only torment, as he is unable to let things go . All the things he holds onto destroy him In the end .

When observing the events that take place in the play , it is evident that pride does play a major role to get events moving in flow with the suspense of the plot .

It is pride that motivates Oedipus to look for a solution to the plague , that brings him to dishonor oracles and the blind prophet .

 

“You are a sightless , witless ,senseless , mad old man”

  • Oedipus Rex

 

Pride and agitation still  brings him to argue with his brother in law . It can also be denial underneath all his anger. He wants the matter to die .

It is the same with Jocasta , she gives no importance to oracles or prophecies . It is only when things become clear to her that she begins to break down and ultimately takes her own life .

 

“All right forget about those things you’ve said

Listen to me and ease your mind with this – no human being has skill in prophecy “

 

Perhaps it is pride that brought her to suicide. Then again humans are capable of feeling more than just pride , maybe it was the immense shock . The horror and the shame that may have overrun her mind and senses .

It is thought by many that the action of taking his eyes out by Oedipus is again nothing more but a show or result of pride again .He does not have any strength anymore , he cannot witness the torment he tried for so long to run away from . Of course it may also be an act of self harm and sacrifice – he no loner runs away . He does not try to escape his horrible fate anymore now that the ultimate damage is done . He does however make plans of protection for his children.

With this is mind it is apparent that pride is indeed a major catalyst – but far long before Oedipus was born there was  a curse on the family . Was it destiny from the very first day , mere chance that pushed everything .it was  Human compassion that saved Oedipus once when he was left to die an infant . It was human love and loneliness that made him a prince again . It was human folly , a drunk man who caused him to search for an oracle – at the end it was the will of the gods that won the toll on his life .

The plagues itself that eats Thebes came when the gods decided to remember the curse . After all those years of peace , it is the plague which opens and inquiry into all that is suppressed . Almost like a journey into the depths of the mind in search of a tangled truth .

However , we cannot decide fully what factors brought out the disaster . It is perhaps a mixture of both fate and human action . In “The kiss of the snow Queen “ the writer gives the example of a girl Greda who travels to the far ends of the south pole to save her friend kai from the snow queen . The queen is the personification of winter and the forces of nature . She in a way seduces the boy and takes him way . Greda who is innocent and personifies spring  makes a journey and effort to save her love . So it is God who saves people but only through the struggle of pure hearted individuals does salvation come .

Much like the sacrifice Jesus Christ had to make to save humanity. It is Greda’s kiss and love that saves the boy from freezing to death while solving a mathematical problem . A triumph of human compassion over human reason – Oedipus sadly has no one to make the effort for him. Jocasta leaves him alone and he cannot even return to the love of his step mother .

This failure of love is the true element that brings out the pessimistic tone in the end of the play . The reminder that man is alone and at the mercy of his fate .

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hamlet : The plight of the Intellectual

image

Hamlet , a play by William Shakespeare, about a young prince looking for revenge , has inspired audiences for many years and been the subject of many theories. A revenge play , to some an expression of the Oedipus complex ,for others , and  a simple yet tragic tale of a hero . I see it as the turbulence  a person has to go through,  once their  ignorance is no longer blissful. It is a  journey into the stressful and challenging loss of Innocence that self-awareness can bring about  and a window into the reality of the soul’s education .

For the sake of this written piece , lets look at Hamlet as someone who has come of age , and looking at the world with a new vision . A more wholesome vision , one filled with cleverness , insight and melancholy .

The play is a treasure of philosophy,  wisdom , and well crafted poetic genius,  and although being a renaissance play it has been praised for  characteristically being post modern because of the psychological and emotional depth the characters have .

 

In this world we live in – knowledge, intelligence and intellect  are highly respected, valued and envied . The intelligent, according to some, are the ones who survive.  The reason man believed himself to be  above all other species is because he was  able to think. Man became the ultimate species due to the size of his brain , up to the point were some scientists were actually measuring the circumference of skulls among the different races of man . But there is a dark side to this  wonder , a realm filled with sacrifices , nihilism,  cynicism,  anxiety,  madness and cruelty .
All of which we explore   through Hamlet.
The play opens with the presence of Fortinbras and the ghost . Fortinbras is the angel of death and the reminder of something rotten in Denmark . The ghost is the symbol of knowledge, madness and an exclusive higher intellect .
Regarding the murder of the late king , only Hamlet and Claudius , his uncle ,know the truth, that Claudius poisoned him to become king . They remain the most anxious and suspicious throughout the play , because they have something to hide , and as result their behavior remains a mystery to the rest of the characters who are oblivious to the ‘ rotten matter’
Hamlet is the noble holder of knowledge,  seeking nothing but justice and revenge for his father , while Claudius is like a Machiavellian intellectual, who  uses spies and words to control or get on Hamlet’s nerves . He later humanizes Hamlet by calling him mad in order to turn others against him. There is no art in Hamlet, in the beginning of the play, he is honest and blunt . He only shows a more a sly disposition when tries to match his uncle in scheming or plotting .

” I know not seems “

Hamlet our main intellectual in his rather numbed aggressive state of being unable to make peace with his surroundings , is always  restless . Questioning events, heaven and morality – he never acts or claims to not have enough knowledge,  despite continuously manifesting his intelligence to the others.
His conflict is being too unfeeling,  filled with so many thoughts and hazards that prevent him from raw emotions.  Time and time again he reminds himself to remain calm and think over the situation and act civilized and controlled. This very behavior disturbs him,  and is the cause of his self-pity and self loathing .

“But break my heart , for I must hold my tongue “
“Let me not take corruption “
“I must not kill him in prayer “
” oh heart lose not thy nature ”

Polonius is the foolish intellectual – full of sage wisdom and gives the most memorable advice in the play .
To thine own self be true “
He is , however  ,  unable to think outside  the box and Hamlet looks down on him.
Tedious old fools”
The intellectual that is sharp looks down on the lesser born children of the intelligent world .

The ghost’s revelations are a heavy burden on Hamlets health. The ghost uses expressions like ‘freeze young blood ‘ ,  and ‘ hair to stand at end ‘ to describe the physical change or shock that Hamlet experiences while learning the truth. 

Stress , worry and anxiety all have physical ailments , and can trouble a person to the point of weakness or laziness .
Later Hamlet encounters Ophelia , in the rags of a frightened,  troubled , shaken mad man burdened with the horrid reality of the world . It is not just mental torture but physically moving and tormenting.  How many men and women have looked at the face of this world and been altered by the abyss that stares back . Haunting,  until it takes us .
He also has to empty himself of everything he once knew to be true in order to accept this new knowledge – even if he does not completely believe the ghost .

” I’ll wipe away all trivial records “
His mind will have to do so , in order not to disagree with this new obsession .
Knowledge also robs Hamlet of his ethics and shame . He sees everyone as a toy . He feels no guilt for the death of his friends or the death of Polonius . He is insensitive to their feelings and unaware of the damage he is causing .
Characters like Sherlock Holmes are also said to be innocently insensitive , just like Hamlet who cannot see the harm he is causing his mother or Ophelia their minds are forever occupied with a certain kind of knowledge that they are unable to conceive any other kind and often lack people skills .
Hamlet knows the trappings of life too much , his character remains the same till the end of the play . The same for all of them, there is no development.  This is his tragedy.  The inability to achieve something . A tragic hero is one whose fall makes the audience either gasp or wonder why , someone so inspirational became a disappointment.
Intellect kills itself in logic and reason when it proves itself to be useless . Reason and cynicism  do not inspire them to act for the better . It cripples their soul , they come to know too much and care to little and see how the small charity will not reach the hungry .

This supernaturally informed and brave prince is crippled by his thoughts , he could have killed Claudius when he was repenting , but decided not to because he believed it would send him to heaven .

The problem with the world is that , stupid people are full of confidence, while the intelligent are full of doubts “
—  Charles Bukowski

Like Moses did not wish to go save the Hebrews,  he was too aware of the deceit, power and corruption he would have to face for the greater good . He knew very well what he would be up against .
Cynicism and nihilism overtake these characters.

” I have of late lost all my mirth “

The very life in them is sucked out by the ugly truth , the duality of human nature and the possibility of every friend being an enemy . All of Hamlet’s speeches are a question and are also like a sophisticated suicide note , one that he can only wish to commit.
” To be or not to be “
Since education numbs emotion and  logic tames the wolf in man to a slow , painless death that goes unnoticed. Hamlet is now wondering where  his spirit is , his anger ? The substance of force and feelings that should compel him towards impulsive action. He is particularly jealous of an actor and soldier for having more emotions.
” oh what a rogue peasant am I “
Hamlet is much too poised and ashamed of his ‘ unpregnant ‘ hate  .
He answers so much yet remains a question – the more he learns the more empty he becomes , like his mother’s sexual appetite.
“Grew with what it fed on ”

image

Then madness . Everyone sees Hamlet as mentally unstable,  Ophelia,  Polonius and his parents believe so.
Madness , itself has been linked with high brain activity,  thus the stereotype of the mad scientist . They all gaze at him in wonder  .
“This is madness , but there is method in it “
“Madness in great ones must not unwatched go “

It is only when Ophelia goes insane , that she becomes outspoken and is confident in what she knows . While at most times , she only listens to what her brother ,father and Hamlet tell her , without any conflict or opposition . She even says something like , I do not know what I should think .

” that’s for thoughts ”

During this time Hamlet is off at sea , which is a symbol of the psyche. He comes home a new man while Ophelia has drowned . Hamlet beats his madness while Ophelia drowns in hers .

Horatio the best friend  and Ophelia the romantic interest  , are like toys or imaginary figures are used as objects of projection for  Hamlet’s feelings towards  his parents.While with Horatio he talks about his father in a grand and loving ,respectable manner , as if he was the greatest of all men  and with Ophelia he complains about his mother , someone who only has his interest in mind and loves him dearly and mocks women in general, because he feels that by marrying his uncle only months after his father’s death is unfaithfulness on her side.

“Brief like women’s love ”

He uses both of them but   trusts Horatio while tormenting Ophelia, by using her . Horatio and Ophelia are also never in the same scene together until she is dead.
They are vessels for the prince to fill up with his philosophy. Hamlet is the one to tell them stories and fill their minds.

” there is more in the heavens and earth , than can be dreamed of in our imagination”

Hamlet is also unable to love or express himself ,  he confesses his love to Ophelia when it is too late . The same with his mother, he spends most of his time ranting about her bit cannot explain to her the reason for his anger  . He decided not to trust anyone with information of the murder, not Horatio and the guards, the Queen or anyone , and guarding it so was angry at everyone for not seeing the crime right in front of his eyes   .
He only has one request at the end

“Tell my story ”
To which we bid him goodnight .

The entire play asks the question ” what good is intellect?  What purpose does it serve ? What problem does it solve ?

Dr Faustus sold his soul for forbidden knowledge and did nothing   . Medea is scorned for her knowledge of spells and herbs , the devil in paradise lost insists that God loves Adam and Eve more because they are dumb and it was after they ate from the tree of knowledge that they were cast out . Daisy from the Great Gatsby wants her daughter to grow up to be .. a beautiful little fool .
Baba Bulleh Shah asks us
” you read thousands of books did you ever read yourself ?

With the final entry of Fortinbras the madness is nowhere to be seen .

image

Lost and found childhood

image

When you’re a kid
Its fun to play hide and seek
Even if the place is no rain forest
Just three rooms
But you everthing just seems bigger
Full of mystery and possibility
Behind curtains or sofas
Under the table
Or inside the cupboard
Anyplace you can find
Resisting the urge to laugh
Or talk to loud
You loved attention
You loved playing with the pigeons

image

Falling asleep on the couch while watching cartoons
Waking up to the sun in your tiny  bed
You liked attending parties and having to be dressed up and making new friends with no effort at all
While the grown ups talked in the living room
You ran all over the house and talked sense about absolutely nothing
And the thing you wanted most was attention

image

From everyone all the time
Then you eventually got older
Maybe you took longer than everyone else – a late blossom
You didnt want to be found anymore
You had to talk business and plot out your sentences paying extreme attention to the other person
You had to let go of your parents hand , even if they say they will always love you
Success will buy you love
No more attention needed
Maybe just from one person

image